Your Best Buyer May Already Be Your Tenant!
The Unexpected Sale of a Scottsdale Medical Office Investment
How a Scottsdale Medical Office Tenant Became the Perfect Buyer
Dear Business Owner:
Real-life commercial real estate transactions don’t always follow the expected path. In this series, I share the behind-the-scenes stories of how market knowledge, creative thinking, and a little persistence turn challenges into win-win solutions—even when the going gets tough!
Who is the best buyer for a single-tenant commercial investment property?
Sometimes it’s an investor searching for dependable rental income. Sometimes it’s a business owner looking to build equity. And sometimes, the perfect buyer is already paying rent inside your building.
This is the story of a Scottsdale medical office investment, an impatient seller, 25 interested investors, and a doctor who unexpectedly became his own landlord.
The Investment: A Landlord’s Dream
Imagine owning a charming, freestanding medical office building nestled in a desirable Scottsdale residential community. Your tenant, a successful medical practitioner, has occupied the property for more than 20 years. He pays rent on time, maintains the building, and operates under a seven-year lease with four years remaining.
Every month, the rent arrives in your bank account like royalties. Life is good!
But after three years of collecting attractive investment returns, another opportunity catches your eye. It’s closer to home, and you want to move quickly. You decide to sell your Scottsdale commercial investment property.
After interviewing several Arizona commercial real estate brokers, you choose one who understands the market, thinks creatively, and shares your sense of urgency.
Davis Commercial AZ, me.
I Want It Now!
“Andrea, when I get an idea, I act on it. How soon can we list the property? What’s the market like? This new opportunity won’t wait forever,” Mitch announces.
“Mitch, commercial real estate takes patience. Unless you want to sell at a discount, we need to position the property properly.” I say.
“Well, how long will it take?”
“First, have you asked your tenant whether he’d like to purchase the building?” Silence.
As a commercial real estate listing broker, I realize I’m potentially suggesting a solution that could change my marketing plans. But the doctor’s business has depended on this location for decades. He already knows the property, and medical professionals may have access to attractive owner-user financing options.
“Last time we talked, he wasn’t interested,” Mitch replies. “But I’ll ask again. Meanwhile, how long will it take?”
Mitch wants answers, and preferably yesterday.
Understanding the Scottsdale Investment Market
Before recommending a listing price, the team analyzes comparable commercial investment sales, location, lease terms, rental income, and buyer demand. The property is near the heart of Scottsdale, in an established area where commercial real estate opportunities are limited.
At the time of the transaction, single-tenant commercial investments with dependable tenants were attracting significant interest. The doctor’s remaining four-year lease provided an income stream, although some investors preferred longer lease commitments.
I call Mitch with a plan.
“First, we’ll professionally photograph the property, prepare a compelling investment brochure, and create a targeted marketing campaign. Then we’ll launch on commercial web platforms, and through our commercial investor network.”
“How long?” Mitch is impatient.
“Allow approximately two weeks for preparation. Then we’ll need time to secure a buyer, complete due diligence, and close escrow. I’d plan on roughly three months, assuming everything goes smoothly.”
Mitch hesitates. “I think that can work. But if we don’t sell within three months, I’ll probably have to reconsider.”
No pressure!
Twenty-Five Investors in Two Days
Location, location, location. Sometimes the old saying really does hold true. Within two days of launching our marketing campaign, 25 prospective buyers express interest. The response confirms our pricing and marketing strategy are attracting attention.
But conversations with the investors reveal something important. Several are willing to consider a higher purchase price if the doctor’s lease can be extended to seven years or longer.
Why? Because a longer lease with a reliable tenant can provide greater income predictability and reduce near-term vacancy risk. For some investors, that stability translates into a willingness to pay more.
I call Mitch.
The Lease Extension Opportunity
“Mitch, several investors are interested, but they would place greater value on the property if the doctor extended his lease. Do you think he’d consider it?” I ask.
“Why would he do that?”
In the background, an airport announcement crackles over the loudspeaker. “American Flight 278, now boarding.”
“Because he has only four years remaining and no contractual renewal option. His practice has been there for over 20 years. Relocating could be expensive and disruptive.” I say. “An extension could provide predictable occupancy costs and protect him from having to negotiate an entirely new lease at market rates when the current term expires.”
“Final boarding call for American Flight 278!”
Mitch is listening. “I see what you’re getting at. I’ll call the doctor when I land.”
Twelve hours later, Mitch calls. “Dr. Patel is interested. Give him a call and explain the lease extension.”
Then I ask one more question. “May I also discuss the possibility of him buying the building?”
“Sure, but I’ve known him for years. He’s not going to buy it.” Mitch hangs up. We’ll see.
Planting the Seed
Dr. Patel has ten minutes between patients. We meet at his office.
“Doctor, you have an opportunity to control your occupancy costs for years to come. Mitch is willing to consider extending your lease with modest annual rent increases.”
I explain that a negotiated lease amendment could provide stability and protect the practice from an unexpected relocation.
“It’s a good plan,” Dr. Patel says. “Let’s do it.”
I could coordinate the amendment, market the improved lease terms to investors, and potentially secure a sale. But something bothers me. The doctor has been paying rent on this building for more than two decades. He knows every room, every improvement, and every quirk of the property.
Why shouldn’t he own it? I clear my throat. “Dr. Patel, have you considered what would happen if you purchased the building instead?”
He looks up. “Go on.”
“Based on preliminary financing estimates, your monthly loan payment could be approximately $1,000 less than your current rent. You’re already responsible for much of the building’s maintenance under your lease.”
I pause. “Instead of paying someone else’s mortgage, you could be building equity in your own real estate.”
Now I have his attention.
The Ultimate Control Over Your Rental Destiny
For a medical practitioner, owning the building where the practice operates can provide several advantages. Ownership may offer greater control over occupancy, the opportunity to build equity through loan principal repayment, and potential long-term appreciation. It may also create an asset that can eventually be sold, leased, or incorporated into retirement and succession planning.
Of course, ownership also involves responsibilities, including property taxes, insurance, maintenance, capital improvements, and financing costs. But Dr. Patel already knows the building. And the preliminary numbers are compelling.
“What would I need to do?” he asks. We discuss financing, down payment requirements, lender underwriting, and the purchase process.
Dr. Patel engages his own buyer representative to help navigate the acquisition and financing. Mitch has a potential buyer. The doctor has an opportunity to become his own landlord. And the building may never need another investor tour.
Behind the Scenes: The Financing Surprise
Dr. Patel scrambles to assemble his down payment while the lender works through the financing requirements. Behind the scenes, we’re coordinating with the buyer’s representative, lender, title company, and Mitch to keep the transaction moving forward.
Every day brings another phone call, another document, and another deadline. Mitch is anxious to move on to his next investment, while Dr. Patel is determined not to lose the opportunity to own the building he’s occupied for more than 20 years.
Finally, the pieces fall into place.
The financing is approved, the paperwork is signed, and escrow closes approximately two weeks later than Mitch’s original three-month goal. For Mitch, three and a half months feels like forever. For those of us navigating commercial real estate financing, due diligence, and escrow, it feels like a small miracle!
Do the Math: The Power of Ownership
Dr. Patel’s preliminary financing analysis indicated a potential savings of approximately $1,000 per month compared with his previous rent. That’s $12,000 annually in payment differences. Over time, principal repayment may also create equity in the property.
However, a mortgage payment isn’t the entire cost of ownership. Taxes, insurance, maintenance, reserves, financing fees, and future capital expenses must also be considered. Commercial loans can have shorter terms than their amortization schedules, creating refinancing or balloon-payment obligations.
The important lesson?
Compare the total cost of leasing against the total cost of owning, not just the monthly rent against the mortgage payment.
For Dr. Patel, the opportunity aligned with his long-term business goals.
Victory Points: Everyone Wins
- Win #1 — The Seller: Mitch sold his Scottsdale investment property at the asking price and was able to pursue another investment opportunity.
- Win #2 — The Doctor: Dr. Patel purchased the building his practice had occupied for more than 20 years, gaining greater control over his business location.
- Win #3 — Long-Term Wealth: Instead of continuing to pay rent indefinitely, the doctor began building equity in a commercial property.
- Win #4 — Creative Representation: By looking beyond the traditional investor pool, we identified a buyer who already understood and valued the property.
The best solution wasn’t necessarily the most obvious one.
Dear Business Owner: The Name of the Game
$$$ Tip: Before selling a single-tenant commercial investment, ask whether your existing tenant has an interest in purchasing. An owner-user may value the property differently than a traditional investor.
Business Owner Tip: If you’ve leased the same location for years, periodically evaluate the financial benefits of purchasing. Ownership may offer greater control, long-term stability, and an opportunity to build equity.
Davis-ism: Sometimes the best investment opportunity isn’t across town. It’s right in your own backyard.
Frequently Asked Questions About Buying and Selling Single-Tenant Commercial Properties
It’s often worth exploring. An established tenant already knows the property and may value its location and improvements. However, the landlord should also evaluate market demand and pricing before deciding how to proceed.
Yes. Qualified medical professionals may obtain conventional commercial financing or certain SBA-backed loans for eligible owner-occupied properties. Down payments, occupancy requirements, loan terms, and underwriting standards vary.
It can. For an investment buyer, a longer lease with a financially stable tenant may reduce vacancy risk and improve income predictability. The effect on value also depends on rental rates, lease structure, tenant credit, and market conditions.
That depends on available capital, financing costs, business growth plans, occupancy needs, tax considerations, and investment goals. Leasing offers flexibility, while purchasing can provide control and equity-building opportunities.
An owner-user purchases commercial property primarily to operate their business. An investment buyer generally purchases property to generate rental income and potentially benefit from appreciation.
Yes. A tenant and landlord can negotiate a purchase while the lease remains active. The parties should address how the existing lease will be handled at closing, including any relevant entity, financing, and legal considerations.
Considering a Commercial Investment Sale or Purchase in Arizona?
At Davis Commercial AZ, we believe successful commercial real estate transactions begin with understanding the people behind the property.
Whether you’re selling a Scottsdale medical office investment, evaluating a single-tenant asset, or considering purchasing the building your business occupies, the right strategy can make all the difference.
Our team combines Arizona market expertise, innovative marketing, strategic negotiation, and personalized platinum-level service to help clients make informed commercial real estate decisions.
Before you look across town for your next opportunity, let’s talk about what’s already in your backyard.
Andrea Davis, CCIM – Owner & Designated Broker | Davis Commercial AZ
Explore more real-life commercial real estate stories in our Dear Business Owner series and discover Andrea’s books, SimpLEASEity and Simply Own It.
Related Posts
Manufacture Urgency: The Commercial Real Estate Marketing Strategy That Attracted Three Offers in One Day
Dear Business Owner: These real-life commercial real estate stories illustrate how creative thinking, market knowledge,…
I’m sorry…
If you have been in business long enough, you have made a mistake. I certainly…
Great Residential Agents Aren’t Automatically Commercial Experts
Every year, I see more residential agents venture into commercial real estate. On the surface,…
Why Commercial Real Estate Is More Than Bringing a Buyer
Recently, I attended a continuing education class where the discussion turned to commercial real estate…